Chocolate and Gold Coins

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Public Goods – Who Should Pay?

My family saw a silly children’s movie on Sunday: Hoot. It is about some teenagers who fight to protect a group of endangered owls from an evil developer.

The movie was not as bad as you might first think. It was really pretty funny for the most part. In typical children’s movie style, all of the adults are nitwits or comic villains and only the children act like ordinary people. It feeds the ego of children to see other children as more capable than adults.

But the plot of the story was not only a cliché but a dangerous economic lesson as well. The evil developer ignores the protected wildlife that they are endangering by developing the land. In the climax, the villain faced with the prospect of loosing his land to the owls threatens to bulldoze a group of citizens assembled for the groundbreaking ceremony. It doesn’t sound funny, and although it is played for laughs it really isn’t all that funny.

But the message is unmistakable: corporations are basically evil organizations with tons of money that they greedily amass and should be forced to pay for the good of the community. Now, it is true that corporations really don’t care for the environment or any other public good (unless it is built into their profit function) and so they might have incentive to break the law to avoid paying a big fine or, in this case, to avoid loosing their land. But I wonder how many people watching the movie wondered if the law – by forcing the entire burden of protecting the owls on the landowner – might create criminals who otherwise might be honest.

Protecting the environment is a pure public good. Who should pay for that good? A simple and fair method would be to make those who benefit most from that good pay for it. If one could know how much each person was willing to pay for the public good, then taxing each person in proportion to his or her benefit would be fair. Of course, it is difficult to impossible to get people to reveal how much they are willing to pay because they cannot be excluded from the good after it is bought. But it is reasonable that most people’s willingness to pay would be close to the same fraction of income. If the community votes to tax each person’s income (or home value) by a fix amount to pay for the good, then the outcome will be roughly fair.

Why then do people think it is fair that only those unlucky enough to have protected animals on their property should have to pay the entire burden of protecting these animals? It is exactly like a community confiscating a person’s home for building a school or a road and not even paying fair market value as compensation. How is that fair?

I used to think that such a confiscation was a bummer for the homeowner but not necessarily economically inefficient. But I realize now that if you place too high a tax burden on a few, they will have incentive to waste precious time and resources to shift that burden onto others. They will also have much more than the ordinary incentive to break the law.

People support these laws because they enjoy the benefits of the environment without having to pay for it. They like to think that it is fair because the only ones who suffer are “evil corporations”. But isn’t getting a benefit without paying for it basically evil?


  • You might have a point about unfair burden on property owners regards conservation. But in that case, the law clearly specifies just compensation under eminent domain under the larger purview of public interest. Probably, that is one of the reasons a government (controlled by an alert judiciary) is useful.

    Check out Nollan v.California Coastal Commission (483 U.S. 825).

    By Blogger Patrix, at 8:43 PM  

  • am sorry haven't read the post fully... just that it is good to see you back n your blog after a long time... see you later here after I read this :)

    By Anonymous Charu, at 9:31 AM  

  • as discussed in your post, such laws provide a big incentive for the landowner to get rid off endenganred flora and fauna from his/her property. A similar allegation has been made against the Vedanta corporation of cleaning up endengared wildlife from thir land in Orissa. Also private breeding of endengared species should be allowed. China has taken such a step in regard to Tiger conservation.

    By Blogger Aditya Dash, at 2:31 AM  

  • There is not going to links of london uk happen such a difficulty that you can't find cheap links of london bracelet an identical topaz jewelry according to your costume. cheap links of london charms It is monitored that besides the reality that it's a links of london watch uk great present to gift, it's also preferred by many people just for the links of london ring uk sake of an inclusion to their own jewelry collection. However, links of london necklaces uk if you'd really like to satisfy your partner and guarantee that she adores your present on this special date.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:28 PM  

  • You must also make sure that it signifies the bond between thomas sabo bracelet you and your partner, who have come from different ethnicity, discount thomas sabo bracelet background and of course have different personalities and way of thinking. And if you are looking for perfect ring then you must also make sure that the ring which have selected for cheap thomas sabo bracelet your bride must fulfil all her requirements in terms of style, design and metal. thomas sabo bracelet clearance You can find host of choices in wedding rings ranging from traditional to modern designs. You can also engrave some personal messages on your ring as a reminder and expression of your lifetime commitment. But no matter whether you are buying wedding rings that are already available in the market or you are designing your thomas sabo charm bracelet own ring it is good to allow your lady to select the ring for herself. This will help in you in your selection and you will be also satisfied that your lady will love the ring. Your lady will wear thomas sabo bracelets uk the ring everyday for her rest of the life. Hence you must make sure that you are selecting the best ring for her. thomas sabo charms bracelet And today you can find that thomas sabo sale uk there are many online jewellery stores offering wide variety of rings for affordable prices and has made the selection thomas sabo jewellery much easier for you. Celtic jewelry designs have a very thomas sabo silver ancient heritage. The history of Celtic Art is fascinating, rich with myth, folklore and mystery.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:11 AM  

  • It should be fair and profitable for both sides. Because people consume goods which produce evil corporations. And if they want keep having it they have to make some sacrifices. It works for assignment writing uk as well. We all make some sacrifices in order to improve our level of life.

    By Blogger John Unger, at 5:45 AM  

  • Excellent stuff from you. I’ve read your things before and you are just too awesome. I adore what you have got right here. You make it entertaining and you still manage to keep it smart.This is truly a great blog thanks for sharing.

    college paper writing service

    By Blogger Ernest Blair, at 1:22 AM  

  • Nice post, I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your blog.

    term paper writing service

    By Blogger Jason Jason K. Schaefer, at 1:09 AM  

  • I realize now that if you place too high a tax burden. dissertation help

    By Blogger Elsa Manley, at 4:31 AM  

  • A simple and fair method would be to make those who benefit most from that good pay for it. Buy assignment uk

    By Blogger angelacooper, at 12:12 AM  

  • It is good to see such high-quality website and reading amazing content. 10/10 for your efforts. Students looking to seek assignment help online can visit our site and can expect to get a decent assignment writing solution. Assignment Help

    By Blogger Michael Jones, at 6:16 AM  

  • Get the best assignment help from at affordable prices. Assignment help | Need Assignment help

    By Anonymous Assignment Help, at 3:41 AM  

  • Couldn't be written any better. Reading this post reminds me of my old roommate! He always kept talking about this Assignment help| Need Assignment help

    By Anonymous Assignment Help, at 12:57 PM  

  • I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well need a photographer| content writers

    By Blogger talha, at 5:19 AM  

  • In Cause and Effect Essay writing Students can't get high grades, because the format of Cause & Effect Essays writing is very difficult. Most of Students don't know about, how to write Cause and Effect Essay they need an Experts help who complete their Cause and Essay Writing.

    By Blogger Stella WILLIAMS, at 6:13 AM  

  • It is superb content I thought and even I was searching similar this subject articles for knowing about it. And I truly enjoyed to read plus collected a tremendous information about it. Custom Essay Writing Service

    By Blogger elton brown, at 1:54 AM  

  • Generally I don't read anything but thanks for writing when i read this i felt how graceful as a writer you are.thank you for posting- Write My Essays

    By Blogger Judyjen, at 12:45 AM  

  • Students who are in USA can now get a good quality essay help paper from It is guaranteed to customers that the papers that they give meet the high university standards.

    By Blogger Dave Leena, at 3:53 AM  

  • Great site and a great topic as well I really get amazed to read this. It’s really good. I like viewing web sites which comprehend the price of delivering the excellent useful resource free of charge. candid photographers | Freelance jobs | freelance web designer |

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:44 AM  

  • Couldn't be written any better. Reading this post reminds me of my old roommate! He always kept talking about this Literature Review Assignment help

    Assignment help| Need Assignment help

    By Anonymous assignment, at 3:44 AM  

  • I guess the information shared here is of utmost importance of Pakistaneo .
    A very helpful Pakistaneo information given.
    Great writing skill shown by the author.
    Thanks for this post.

    By Blogger Sarah jennifer, at 2:39 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home