Public Goods – Who Should Pay?
My family saw a silly children’s movie on Sunday: Hoot. It is about some teenagers who fight to protect a group of endangered owls from an evil developer.
The movie was not as bad as you might first think. It was really pretty funny for the most part. In typical children’s movie style, all of the adults are nitwits or comic villains and only the children act like ordinary people. It feeds the ego of children to see other children as more capable than adults.
But the plot of the story was not only a cliché but a dangerous economic lesson as well. The evil developer ignores the protected wildlife that they are endangering by developing the land. In the climax, the villain faced with the prospect of loosing his land to the owls threatens to bulldoze a group of citizens assembled for the groundbreaking ceremony. It doesn’t sound funny, and although it is played for laughs it really isn’t all that funny.
But the message is unmistakable: corporations are basically evil organizations with tons of money that they greedily amass and should be forced to pay for the good of the community. Now, it is true that corporations really don’t care for the environment or any other public good (unless it is built into their profit function) and so they might have incentive to break the law to avoid paying a big fine or, in this case, to avoid loosing their land. But I wonder how many people watching the movie wondered if the law – by forcing the entire burden of protecting the owls on the landowner – might create criminals who otherwise might be honest.
Protecting the environment is a pure public good. Who should pay for that good? A simple and fair method would be to make those who benefit most from that good pay for it. If one could know how much each person was willing to pay for the public good, then taxing each person in proportion to his or her benefit would be fair. Of course, it is difficult to impossible to get people to reveal how much they are willing to pay because they cannot be excluded from the good after it is bought. But it is reasonable that most people’s willingness to pay would be close to the same fraction of income. If the community votes to tax each person’s income (or home value) by a fix amount to pay for the good, then the outcome will be roughly fair.
Why then do people think it is fair that only those unlucky enough to have protected animals on their property should have to pay the entire burden of protecting these animals? It is exactly like a community confiscating a person’s home for building a school or a road and not even paying fair market value as compensation. How is that fair?
I used to think that such a confiscation was a bummer for the homeowner but not necessarily economically inefficient. But I realize now that if you place too high a tax burden on a few, they will have incentive to waste precious time and resources to shift that burden onto others. They will also have much more than the ordinary incentive to break the law.
People support these laws because they enjoy the benefits of the environment without having to pay for it. They like to think that it is fair because the only ones who suffer are “evil corporations”. But isn’t getting a benefit without paying for it basically evil?
The movie was not as bad as you might first think. It was really pretty funny for the most part. In typical children’s movie style, all of the adults are nitwits or comic villains and only the children act like ordinary people. It feeds the ego of children to see other children as more capable than adults.
But the plot of the story was not only a cliché but a dangerous economic lesson as well. The evil developer ignores the protected wildlife that they are endangering by developing the land. In the climax, the villain faced with the prospect of loosing his land to the owls threatens to bulldoze a group of citizens assembled for the groundbreaking ceremony. It doesn’t sound funny, and although it is played for laughs it really isn’t all that funny.
But the message is unmistakable: corporations are basically evil organizations with tons of money that they greedily amass and should be forced to pay for the good of the community. Now, it is true that corporations really don’t care for the environment or any other public good (unless it is built into their profit function) and so they might have incentive to break the law to avoid paying a big fine or, in this case, to avoid loosing their land. But I wonder how many people watching the movie wondered if the law – by forcing the entire burden of protecting the owls on the landowner – might create criminals who otherwise might be honest.
Protecting the environment is a pure public good. Who should pay for that good? A simple and fair method would be to make those who benefit most from that good pay for it. If one could know how much each person was willing to pay for the public good, then taxing each person in proportion to his or her benefit would be fair. Of course, it is difficult to impossible to get people to reveal how much they are willing to pay because they cannot be excluded from the good after it is bought. But it is reasonable that most people’s willingness to pay would be close to the same fraction of income. If the community votes to tax each person’s income (or home value) by a fix amount to pay for the good, then the outcome will be roughly fair.
Why then do people think it is fair that only those unlucky enough to have protected animals on their property should have to pay the entire burden of protecting these animals? It is exactly like a community confiscating a person’s home for building a school or a road and not even paying fair market value as compensation. How is that fair?
I used to think that such a confiscation was a bummer for the homeowner but not necessarily economically inefficient. But I realize now that if you place too high a tax burden on a few, they will have incentive to waste precious time and resources to shift that burden onto others. They will also have much more than the ordinary incentive to break the law.
People support these laws because they enjoy the benefits of the environment without having to pay for it. They like to think that it is fair because the only ones who suffer are “evil corporations”. But isn’t getting a benefit without paying for it basically evil?
66 Comments:
am sorry haven't read the post fully... just that it is good to see you back n your blog after a long time... see you later here after I read this :)
By Anonymous, at 9:31 AM
as discussed in your post, such laws provide a big incentive for the landowner to get rid off endenganred flora and fauna from his/her property. A similar allegation has been made against the Vedanta corporation of cleaning up endengared wildlife from thir land in Orissa. Also private breeding of endengared species should be allowed. China has taken such a step in regard to Tiger conservation.
By Aditya Dash, at 2:31 AM
You must also make sure that it signifies the bond between thomas sabo bracelet you and your partner, who have come from different ethnicity, discount thomas sabo bracelet background and of course have different personalities and way of thinking. And if you are looking for perfect ring then you must also make sure that the ring which have selected for cheap thomas sabo bracelet your bride must fulfil all her requirements in terms of style, design and metal. thomas sabo bracelet clearance You can find host of choices in wedding rings ranging from traditional to modern designs. You can also engrave some personal messages on your ring as a reminder and expression of your lifetime commitment. But no matter whether you are buying wedding rings that are already available in the market or you are designing your thomas sabo charm bracelet own ring it is good to allow your lady to select the ring for herself. This will help in you in your selection and you will be also satisfied that your lady will love the ring. Your lady will wear thomas sabo bracelets uk the ring everyday for her rest of the life. Hence you must make sure that you are selecting the best ring for her. thomas sabo charms bracelet And today you can find that thomas sabo sale uk there are many online jewellery stores offering wide variety of rings for affordable prices and has made the selection thomas sabo jewellery much easier for you. Celtic jewelry designs have a very thomas sabo silver ancient heritage. The history of Celtic Art is fascinating, rich with myth, folklore and mystery.
By Anonymous, at 2:11 AM
It should be fair and profitable for both sides. Because people consume goods which produce evil corporations. And if they want keep having it they have to make some sacrifices. It works for assignment writing uk as well. We all make some sacrifices in order to improve our level of life.
By rideoo, at 5:45 AM
Excellent stuff from you. I’ve read your things before and you are just too awesome. I adore what you have got right here. You make it entertaining and you still manage to keep it smart.This is truly a great blog thanks for sharing.
college paper writing service
By Unknown, at 1:22 AM
Nice post, I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your blog.
term paper writing service
By Unknown, at 1:09 AM
I realize now that if you place too high a tax burden. dissertation help
By Unknown, at 4:31 AM
In Cause and Effect Essay writing Students can't get high grades, because the format of Cause & Effect Essays writing is very difficult. Most of Students don't know about, how to write Cause and Effect Essay they need an Experts help who complete their Cause and Essay Writing.
By singapore translators, at 6:13 AM
It is superb content I thought and even I was searching similar this subject articles for knowing about it. And I truly enjoyed to read plus collected a tremendous information about it. Custom Essay Writing Service
By elton brown, at 1:54 AM
Generally I don't read anything but thanks for writing when i read this i felt how graceful as a writer you are.thank you for posting- Write My Essays
By Unknown, at 12:45 AM
I guess the information shared here is of utmost importance of Pakistaneo .
A very helpful Pakistaneo information given.
Great writing skill shown by the author.
Thanks for this post.
By Unknown, at 2:39 PM
I am an antique article collector and this article is one of the best I have ever read. I hope to see the same amazing work from you in future.
Nursing Assignment Help
By Unknown, at 3:12 AM
Thank You So Much For providing the important information.
I am Max Willor, SEO Expert in a reputed company. All of your information is very useful to me. I am working as an academic consultant in Australia and offer Excellent My Assignment Help Services to college students.
By Max Willor, at 12:39 AM
Hello
My name is Sarah Smith and This is a very nice post. Thanks for sharing with us. Keep it up
24*7 My Assignment Help anytime in UK.
By Sarah Smith, at 4:19 AM
Receive assignment on project management from qualified tutors and submit quality assignment on time.
By Unknown, at 1:21 PM
Hello
Nice post. Cheap Assignment Help in Australia.
By Cheap Assignment Help, at 1:42 AM
Get besteconomics assignment help for students
By john smith, at 6:13 AM
Xandertlcu988blog
Mylesytkd211blog
Dawsonvneu495blog
Ezraawoj138blog
Rubenvqia111blog
Fabianpizr394blog
Amirunbp160blog
Nolanxrja111blog
Ezrakewo665blog
Enriqueojbv516blog
By Sahib Khan, at 10:11 AM
This post is not just informative but impressive also. The post is so convincing that it created an urge to choose Java Development Service.
By MobileAppDevelopment, at 6:17 AM
Best Web and Mobile Application solution provider Locus Rags in India.
By Anonymous, at 1:34 AM
Best Web and Mobile Application solution provider Locus Rags in India.
By Anonymous, at 1:35 AM
his is marco stefan, Thanks for Sharing this.
network information security assignment help
By marcostefan992, at 5:41 AM
this is marco stefan, Thanks for Sharing this.
network information security assignment help
By marcostefan992, at 5:42 AM
Hire assignment writers in Texas on Texas assignment helpers for getting assignment help in any subject. StudentsAssignmentHelp.com have the team of assignment writers that experience holders.
By Stefan Carl, at 5:24 AM
Thanks for sharing a good piece of information, nice post
Best Love SMS In Hindi for your partner.
By Anonymous, at 3:40 PM
Thanks for sharing a good piece of information, nice post
Best Love SMS In Hindi for your partner.
By Anonymous, at 3:41 PM
Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website the details so much information about different artists.
visit here:- ganeshaspeaks for astrology.
By Unknown, at 2:40 PM
Thank you for sharing this informative post.MyAssignmenthelp.co.uk is giving assignment help uk to students.we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want Online marketing assignment help to save their time and make life easy.
By MyAssignmentHelp, at 5:27 AM
Thanks for sharing it's very informative blog.
Asp .Net Development Company
Hire Asp .Net Developer.
Asp .Net Development Services.
Dot Net Development Companies In Chennai.
By asp .net web development company, at 8:23 AM
Best piece of info ever looking forward for more, having a sparkling clean concrete surface can be difficult at times. It requires a lot of effort and time to clean the tough stains and dirt. However, the cleaning of this stubborn dirt and stains can become easier when you are cleaning with the best concrete cleaner. Get one from Best Concrete Cleaner
By pesh, at 11:01 AM
Thank you for sharing the blog with us. Here I want to share about APA referencing. The American Psychological Association, or APA, is the organization that created the language used and understood by academics around the world. APA style is the expected standard in higher education and research papers to ensure sources are cited properly. Despite its universality, the many nuances of academia can make it a difficult language to master. Visit - https://myassignmenthelp.com/us/apa-referencing.html
By Emily Moore, at 7:39 AM
Computer Science Assignment Help is one among the foremost wanted services that we provide to students studying computer sciences in Australia. Our team of experts have well qualified and equipped to supply assistance in any given computer-oriented language and operating systems. With years of industry experience and practical exposures, our subject material experts can provide a mistake free solution to all or any your problems and doing assignments will become a cakewalk.
By Ideal Assignment Help, at 4:18 AM
I have been looking for such great information for some time thanks I finally found it. From sweetbreads to sandwich bread, to gluten-free bread, people are using these handy bread maker machines to replace the less than appetizing store-bought bread. But choosing a bread machine isn’t exactly easy. Visit Best Buy Bread Maker for more.
By Binary, at 6:51 AM
At Al Emad Cars, we provide residents and tourists within the country to rent a car in JBR for the cheapest prices. Customers can choose from over 300+ car currently available in our inventory. You can find popular models from all the leading brands like Nissan, Toyota, and Hyundai in our catalogue. Based on your individual needs and requirements, you choose from a plethora of premium and budget models. For more information about our service or rent a car in JBR, contact our customer support via the live chat feature or call us on +971-56-680-3692.
By Car Rental Jumeirah Beach Residences, at 8:35 AM
Wow admin! Looks so nice and different. The Combination of orange and white looks so unique and beautiful. also i loved your article content information. Thank you so much for sharing thoughts and we want next article SEO niche. So please carry on and share more. Assignment Help Adelaide
By Jessica Jones, at 2:38 AM
It’s a very attractive article thank you for sharing. A Statement of Purpose (SOP) is an application document that basically tells the reader who you are, your professional interests, what has influenced your career as well as your professional goals. The SOP gives you a platform to talk directly to the admissions committee. In other words, a statement of purpose gives you an opportunity to convince the admission committee that you are the right candidate among many qualified applicants. Learn more from SOP Writing Services .
By James Ian, at 2:58 AM
Thank you for sharing such an informative article looking forward for part 2. Cycling outdoor could have been easy and very much achievable during one’s youth but it certainly isn’t in the golden years. Beyond age 60 people tend to tone down to less strenuous exercises. Well, you do not have to switch to other exercises if you are still passionate about cycling. Take advantage of Recumbent Bikes for Seniors .
By Caleb, at 5:29 AM
I have bookmarked your site for regular checkup. Did you know that One of the most recommended pieces of home exercise equipment is a treadmill? This is because it offers an effective aerobic workout for users at any skill or conditioning level. Professional runners and first-time exercisers alike can benefit from this machine, but electric models commonly found in commercial gyms can be prohibitively expensive, as well as intimidating to beginners. Learn more on Reviews on Manual Treadmills .
By Sam Smith, at 2:44 AM
This is a great way of presenting information. Very much quiet information and valuable. Thanks from 1377xx, 7star hd movies, 9x movies, aatmanirbhar bharat, online doctor consultation, bolly share hd.
By Aadhirabedi, at 6:35 AM
Thank you for sharing such a great article. A critique is a document that provides a basic appraisal of a book or editorial, not a feedback. A scrutinize is a particular mode of exposition into which you recognize, assess, also react to a creator's thoughts, together decidedly also adversely. It is generally connected to scholarly sources. When you are writing a critique it has some steps. Read the book or article many time while you are selected. If you are more time read, you can get many points from that book or article. Write a rough note about the author's main points or thesis statements. Read more on Article Critique Homework Help
By James Ian, at 6:15 AM
black friday huge discount
black friday led tv deals 2020
mattress black friday
samsung 43 uhd smart led tv black friday
nest camera black friday
dicks sporting goods black friday sales
black friday led tv deals 2020
mattress black friday
samsung 43 uhd smart led tv black friday
nest camera black friday
By Sahib Khan, at 5:44 AM
I couldn’t ignore the art of writing you have to ensure you deliver the best. If you are a student working on a paper that requires data analysis such as a statistical research project or a dissertation on the location of features and boundaries around the earth, the major challenge you are likely to face is getting a better understanding of the data and materials that you’ve gathered. Go ahead and reach out to us for Dissertation Data Analysis Help
By Arif, at 4:25 AM
I have benefited from the content in this blog. The literature review is a written overview of major writings and other sources on a selected topic. Sources covered in the review may include scholarly journal articles, books, government reports, Web sites, etc. The literature review provides a description, summary and evaluation of each source. It is usually presented as a distinct section of a graduate thesis or dissertation. Know more about Literature Review Homework Help
By Silvia, at 4:41 AM
Keep up the good work. The best way to approach your literature review is to break it down into steps. Remember, research is an iterative process, not a linear one. You will revisit steps and revise along the way. Get started with the handout below that provides an excellent overview. Then move on to the specific steps recommended on this page. Read more on Capstone Editing Help
By Caleb, at 7:27 AM
contact us for free
visit here
click there
website
click here
visit now
online
blog
dhook
source
By Sahib Khan, at 6:13 AM
I’ve enjoyed reading through your article. This is a great post. Before you know it, you’ve run out of all of the time. At that point, the project becomes some sort of an emergency. That’s when finding some DNP capstone project help starts feeling conceivable. This page presents a few tips to help you successfully manage the DNP project writing process. Read more on DNP Capstone Project Writing Help .
By Ian , at 3:14 AM
I always come back to your site to gain more insight. If you are about to complete your degree course, the odds are high that you will need to fulfill a capstone project. The aim of this assignment is to assess the knowledge and skills, which you acquired during the course. But before starting looking for nursing capstone project essay ideas, you need to understand the essence of this assignment. Get Help with Capstone Project
.
By Caleb, at 4:00 AM
Gotoassignmenthelp is team of leading professional writers for Do my assignment Writing Services to students all around the world. Contact us today for Best assignment helper at very affordable price. Under GotoAssignmentHelp we provide many types of help to the students. We are the most reliable assignment helpers. We have gained our specialization after spending most of our times in making ourselves perfect. We providing 100% plagiarism free Assignment Help. At the point when you pick our Java help assistance, our faculty will consider the quality and your evaluation criteria.
By Michael McFarlane84, at 12:52 AM
This article has brought to an end my long internet search thank you. You’re a fresh DNP candidate. At this time, it’s too early to start worrying about your DNP capstone project. Possibly, the idea of working with a quality DNP capstone project writing service hasn’t crossed your mind. You still have time, don’t you? But time keeps playing tricks on people. At the start, it may feel like you’ve got more than enough time. Time flies, though. Before you know it, you’ve run out of all of the time. Read more on DNP Project Help
By Euni, at 2:41 AM
This article has brought to an end my long internet search thank you. This ground-breaking book is an indispensable practical guide to the successful execution of research with particular attention to data analysis to arrive at indispensable findings, conclusions, and generalizations. Studying this book endows you with the requisite mastery knowledge for personally applying the most appropriate statistical tests accurately, swiftly, effortlessly and pleasurably in situations of data analysis. It is a most clearly written modern and practical book with simple, direct, easy-to-understand and highly motivating information. Read more on SPSS Research Paper
By Arif, at 1:49 AM
Today, nursing is one of the most important courses in the health care field that is undertaken by many students because it facilitates the preservation of good health in society. Students undertaking a nursing course are required to write a nursing capstone project as an academic requirement before graduating. Need to know how to Write My Nursing Capstone Project
By Unknown, at 1:00 AM
book to lufthansa flights
By K2tickets, at 6:00 AM
Hey, It was amazing to go through your post, that was really so useful and informative!
Resource:
https://www.imgglobalinfotech.com/mobile-app-development-in-jaipur.php
By Gargi Sharma, at 1:14 AM
Apostille Services In Delhi
Business Visa USA
Visa Services Delhi
By Anonymous, at 6:46 AM
This a very Unique and magnificent post with readable and informative content, I'm absolutely impressed. Thank you for Sharing this amazing reads.....kwcoeilorin professional diploma in education form deadline
By zarkazijar, at 3:51 AM
Win All Capsim Simulation Rounds with our astute and expert writers and earn the grades you deserve. We have the best Capsim Simulation Assignment Experts in the market.
By GIS Homework Help, at 1:11 PM
As just consequence, Economics Assignment Help produces information that is highly demanded after for academic advancement. Our subject matter experts are accomplished professionals with degrees from premier colleges in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia. If you are unable to complete or comprehend a complex economics assignment subject, visit our website to quickly.
By Leo Oliver, at 1:55 PM
This page certainly has all of the info I wanted about this subject and didn’t know who to ask. For american airline prices ticket information and booking. Visit- K2tickets
By K2tickets, at 7:00 AM
You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers. For alaska airline flights cheap ticket booking. Visit- Bansal Travels
By Bansal Travels, at 7:08 AM
courier services charges
By Pickrr, at 8:17 AM
Immediate english assignment help services @50%off. Get online english assignment help from Native experts in given deadline. Plagiarism-free, 3000 Experts.
By assignment help, at 3:58 PM
best resources
online medicine sites
MBA finance
best personal injury lawyers
foxpro shockwave predator call
foxpro shockwave predator call
By Sahib Khan, at 4:22 AM
Thanks for sharing im lokking this article and please visit my wesites its relates to high surgerior that helps you in your or any relative health problem . Thanks!!
By best orthopedic doctor in patna, at 4:30 AM
dianabol 20mg pills
stanozolol 20mg
halotestin fluoxymesterone
clenbuterol 40mcg
buy testosterone enanthate 300mg
By karan upadhyay, at 2:44 PM
what an amazing, fun post.
Conference Paper Writing
By Assignment Writing Service, at 6:58 AM
Thanks to sharing this information this information help me lot sir thanks for sharing I am following you since very long time your content is always on top thanks to sharing again
Fmovies
By zonewalton, at 1:23 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home